RE: Rogue Chocolate Stout
You didn't read what I wrote correctly. Those who hate it really hate it. Those who love it really love it. I stand by my opinion; I don't like it, and I don't understand how someone could like it. I would have drainpoured it, except that I'd already paid for it and didn't want to open a bottle of something else. My opinion is that the Alstroms rated it highly, and a lot of people bought it and decided that that must be what good beer tastes like, and they wanted to write something on the internet.
I wouldn't at all call it a consensus, with all the negatives. I suggest you try it and get back to me.
(edited after a nights rest after a bad day)