My wife and I stop there about once a year for quite a few years now. We have had exactly one medicore experience and the rest have been great. By any chance when it was not good did you get there right before closing (either in the middle of the day or at night)? Our one bad experience came when we got there about 20 minutes beofre the 2:00 closing time and the chicken was very dry and seemed like it had been sitting around. So now we just make sure to time it so we get there much earlier in the shift.
We stopped just this past August on the way home from Tybee Island and it was as good if not better than ever. My wife usually orders one chicken breast when she gets fried chicken and eats about half to 3/4 of it. When we go to Keaton's, we order a whole chicken and there is never anything left but the bones. We also always order and extra 8 oz cup of suace on the side and there is never any of that left.
So my recommendation would be to give it another chance but only if you can get there well beofre closing. Good luck!
post edited by hatteras04 - 2012/02/22 09:41:44